monero.loveA little love for the network.
← All news

Monero / Privacy / Research

Monero FCMP++ Status: Testing, Audits and What Comes Next

FCMP++ remains in testing and integration. We review stressnet fixes, cryptographic audits and the milestones still needed before mainnet activation.

A magnifying glass examining charts and connected evidence on layered paper.

Monero's FCMP++ upgrade is progressing through testing, audits, and integration. As of November 20, 2026, the development repository lists beta stressnet v3.1, while the official Monero release announcements still list the 0.18.5 series. We found no confirmed mainnet activation date in the primary announcements checked for this report. Beta releases, Monero announcements

Stressnet runs on a separate experimental network. Its releases let developers test the upgrade without changing the network holding real XMR.

What FCMP++ changes

FCMP++ means Full-Chain Membership Proofs plus Spend Authorization and Linkability. It changes how a transaction proves that its input comes from a valid existing output without revealing which output is being spent.

Monero's current ring-based approach places the real output among decoys, giving each input a ring of 16 candidates. FCMP++ is designed to prove membership across the eligible chain-wide output set instead. This removes dependence on selecting a small ring of decoys and addresses attacks that exploit that selection. Monero's design explanation

Spend authorization establishes that the spender has the required authority. Linkability lets the network detect attempts to spend the same output twice. Expanding the anonymity set must preserve both properties. It does not make a compromised wallet safe or conceal information disclosed outside a transaction.

Stressnet fixes

The October 26 release, tagged v0.19.0.0-beta.3.1, combines FCMP++ with Carrot, the accompanying addressing work. Its notes describe faster wallet scanning, updated seed nodes, and denial-of-service protections in transaction relay and wallet-side tree building. Beta v3.1 release notes

The release also prevents Carrot outputs from being used in ring signatures. Developers describe this as fixing a detectable inflation vulnerability exposed during the 24-hour period after the initial stressnet fork. The release notes describe a stressnet vulnerability and do not report inflation on Monero mainnet.

Testing covers migration behavior, wallet operations and hostile traffic. Fixes still need review before deployment to mainnet.

Audit findings and scope

On August 17, MAGIC Grants published results from a Trail of Bits review of selected cryptography changes. The review involved two engineer-weeks and produced six informational findings, with no low-, medium-, or high-severity findings. Five were resolved and one was partly resolved. MAGIC Grants audit summary

The remaining issue concerned fragile memory-layout assumptions where Rust and other code interact. Compile-time checks were added, but the auditor still described the interface as fragile. The report covered selected implementation changes.

The broader integration audit plan separates cryptography, curve-tree building, and consensus integration. Review and remediation need to cover each part, including later code revisions. Integration audit overview

Generalized Bulletproofs review and formal proof

On November 12, MAGIC Grants published a zkSecurity review of the Generalized Bulletproofs code and cryptography intended for FCMP++. Ten working days of review found four low-severity and three informational issues, with no high- or medium-severity findings. Developers responded to each finding. A response alone does not establish that every issue was resolved. MAGIC Grants report

zkSecurity also published a separate machine-checked Lean proof covering completeness, zero knowledge and soundness of the interactive protocol in an abstract mathematical group. Its scope excludes the non-interactive Fiat-Shamir version, the Rust implementation, the specific curves and the FCMP++ circuits built on top. Those limits matter when judging what the proof establishes. It does not formally verify the entire Monero upgrade.

A branching output tree drawn on cream paper beside a node and drafting tools

What still needs to happen?

The November 11 Monero Research Lab meeting, whose transcript appeared on November 16, reached loose consensus for the bidder called Vendor 6 to handle phase 2 and 3 integration audits. Participants discussed eight bids and a requested reviewer. This records an auditor-selection decision, not completed integration audits. MRL meeting record

Justin Berman said phase 2 was ready to proceed, while phase 3 needed pull request 10916 finalized before supplying the final code revisions for review. Carrot input and output proofs also remained under testing. The November 18 meeting page still had no posted transcript when checked on November 20. We found no confirmed mainnet activation date in the primary announcements checked.

The Rust interface and scalar-conversion change in pull request 10359 merged on August 12. A merged component is progress toward integration, but it does not activate new consensus rules. Upstream pull request

What should users do now?

Keep using supported production releases for real funds. Anyone helping test should follow the stressnet instructions and keep test wallets separate. Verify downloads using the signing information supplied for that release. Our PGP verification guide explains the process.

The next useful milestones are published audit results, reviewed fixes, completed integration, compatible wallet releases, and an official activation announcement. FCMP++ remains in testing and integration, with further review underway.

Support Monero Love

Help keep the public nodes and packages running. Send any amount of XMR.

Scan with a Monero wallet to donate to Monero Love.89hGTKxRVA3AUeKAbCRBt5TMSzq3MQZooNNsezCpNFjp2oeJPRx8AJeGKA8ziHZNqab78f4Vr1ntxhPDxX5298nnGZjHkhm